Available on the Awesome plan
By default, Judge.me Email sends from a shared Judge.me domain (emails.judge.me), which works with no setup. Sending from your own domain can improve deliverability and make your emails look more clearly yours. You'll find it in the Sending domain card on Settings > Sender & tracking.
Considerations
DNS changes aren't instant. Judge.me automatically re-checks your domain once a day, and you can also click Check verification any time to check immediately after updating your records.
Verifying your domain isn't enough on its own — the specific sender address you use to send emails also needs to be on that verified domain. An address on a different domain will still fall back to the shared Judge.me domain, even if you have a verified domain on file.
If a DNS record is later removed or changed and stops verifying, the Sending domain card shows Needs attention and your emails automatically fall back to the shared Judge.me domain until it's fixed.
If your domain is already connected on another of your stores, you don't need to set it up again — see "Using one domain across several stores" below.
How it works
Setting up a custom domain takes three steps:
Add your domain — enter the root domain you want to send from.
Add DNS records — add the records Judge.me gives you to your domain's DNS.
Verify — Judge.me checks the records and activates your domain.
The DNS records cover DKIM, Return-Path, and DMARC, which prove you're allowed to send from the domain and help your emails reach the inbox.
Set up your domain
From your Judge.me Email app, go to Settings > Sender & tracking.
In the Sending domain card, click Add domain.
Enter your domain and click Add domain.
Add the listed DNS records at your domain provider. Judge.me checks your records automatically once a day — or click Check verification to check right away once you've added them.
Once the records are in place, Judge.me verifies them and your domain shows as Active.
Go to Settings > Sender & tracking and update your From email to an address on your newly verified domain. Verifying the domain alone doesn't change what your emails send from — your From email has to actually use it.
Note: If a DNS record later stops verifying, your domain shows as broken and emails fall back to the shared Judge.me domain until it's fixed.
Using one domain across several stores
Once a domain is verified on one store, any other store you own can use it too — no second DNS setup is needed.
When you add a domain that another store is already sending from, Judge.me emails whoever is currently sending from it and asks them to confirm the new store. Your Sending domain page shows a waiting state until any one of them accepts.
If nobody is actively sending from the domain any more (for example, the original store uninstalled), your new store is granted the domain straight away with no approval step.
In both cases, the DNS records stay exactly as they are. One pass of DNS authentication covers every store on the same brand domain.
Troubleshoot
Your sending domain stays In setup after you add the DNS records
Your sending domain stays In setup after you add the DNS records
If the Sending domain card still shows In setup after you've added the DNS records, Judge.me may not have found records that match yet.
Check the following:
The records at your domain provider match exactly what the Sending domain page lists. A typo, or an extra record your provider adds by default, can stop them matching.
Your DNS changes have had time to spread. They can take up to 48 hours.
Once the records match, click Check verification on the Sending domain page to check right away, instead of waiting for the daily check.
Sending domain setup shows "We couldn't finish setting up your domain"
Sending domain setup shows "We couldn't finish setting up your domain"
If the Sending domain page shows We couldn't finish setting up your domain and the Sending domain card shows Needs attention, Judge.me couldn't prepare your domain for sending.
To fix it:
From your Judge.me Email app, go to Settings > Sender & tracking.
In the Sending domain card, click Continue setup.
Click Try again.
If setup still doesn't finish, click Remove domain, then add a different domain.
Sending domain setup shows "This is taking longer than usual"
Sending domain setup shows "This is taking longer than usual"
If the Sending domain page shows This is taking longer than usual, your domain is still being prepared, and the page stopped checking on it after 30 minutes. You can leave the page and come back later, or click Check again to keep checking.
Your sending domain shows Needs attention after it was Active
Your sending domain shows Needs attention after it was Active
If the Sending domain card shows Needs attention and the Sending domain page says some DNS records are no longer verified, a record was changed or removed at your domain provider. Judge.me re-checks verified domains daily, so it catches this on its own. Until the records verify again, your emails send from the shared Judge.me domain.
To fix it:
From your Judge.me Email app, go to Settings > Sender & tracking.
In the Sending domain card, click Fix DNS records.
At your domain provider, add or correct the records the page lists.
Click Check verification.
Emails still send from the shared domain after your sending domain is Active
Emails still send from the shared domain after your sending domain is Active
If your sending domain shows Active but your emails still send from the shared Judge.me domain, your From email may not be on that domain. A verified domain only covers addresses on that exact domain.
To fix it:
From your Judge.me Email app, go to Settings > Sender & tracking.
In the From email field, enter the part before the @ for an address on your verified domain.
Click Save.
Resources
Follow us on LinkedIn:
📢 Stay in the loop! Follow Judge.me on LinkedIn for the latest product updates, tips, and feature launches.

